Educational convergence of Dewantara’s philosophy and Singapore competencies
Ulil Amri Syafri, Rosli Ahmat
Abstract
This study examines the convergence of Ki Hadjar Dewantara’s humanistic educational philosophy and Singapore’s 21st century competencies (21CC) framework within contemporary educational reforms. Although competency-based reforms and indigenous humanistic philosophy are frequently treated as opposing paradigms, comparative education research has rarely examined how they converge across pedagogy, character formation, and educational ecosystems in the Southeast Asian context, leaving this relationship insufficiently understood. Using a qualitative comparative document analysis, the study analyzed 24 philosophical texts, policy documents, and scholarly sources related to Dewantara’s educational thought and Singapore’s competency-based education policies. Data were analyzed through deductive and inductive thematic coding and cross-case comparison across three dimensions: educational purpose, pedagogical orientation, and educational ecosystems. The findings reveal convergence in three major areas: i) the transformation of teachers’ roles from instructional authorities to learning facilitators; ii) the positioning of character education as the ethical foundation of 21CC; and iii) the development of collaborative educational ecosystems involving schools, families, and communities, although important differences remain in historical orientation and policy implementation. This study contributes a conceptual framework of educational convergence that is distinguished from prior comparative work and offers concrete implications for curriculum developers, teacher educators, and policymakers seeking to integrate ethical formation and cultural identity within competency-based education.
Keywords
Character education; Comparative education; Competencies; Humanistic education; Ki Hadjar Dewantara