Responsible adoption of AI in clinical reasoning education: balancing benefits and ethical risks
Hamza Abu Owida, Yazeed Alsarhan, Ayoub Alsarhan, Areen Arabiat
Abstract
Clinical reasoning is central to safe medical practice, yet traditional approaches to teaching and evaluating this competency remain resource-intensive, variably standardized, and often limited in the immediacy of feedback they provide. This scoping review synthesizes literature on the use of artificial intelligence (AI), with particular attention to large language models (LLMs) and generative systems, in clinical reasoning education. The review draws on targeted searches of the medical education and health informatics literature and includes studies that examined AI-supported teaching, simulation, assessment, or feedback related to clinical reasoning development. Across the reviewed literature, AI was consistently described as supporting adaptive learning, dynamic virtual patient simulation, formative feedback, and longitudinal monitoring of learner performance. At the same time, the literature emphasizes important limitations related to reliability, hallucinations, bias, implementation burden, assessment validity, and the risk of learner overreliance on automated outputs. From an educational perspective, the most meaningful contribution of AI lies in its capacity to strengthen practice opportunities and feedback cycles while preserving human judgment, reflective learning, and professional autonomy. The review therefore argues that responsible AI integration in medical education should be aligned with competency-based curricula and evaluation frameworks that prioritize ethical use, critical thinking, and authentic clinical reasoning performance.
Keywords
Artificial intelligence; Clinical reasoning; Educational technology; Ethics; Medical education